Apr 222010

You may or may not have noticed that when you are using the spot removal tool, you can work in either Heal or Clone mode.  Let’s take a look at the difference.

Here is an image before any work:

(c) A. Nowacka

First I clicked on the spot removal tool to select it, and then on Clone:

Let’s do something very obvious for the sake of illustration:  let’s “fix” the father’s cheek, borrowing from the baby’s forehead:

As you can see, Clone is a straight copy of pixels, in this case from the baby’s forehead to the father’s cheek.

Now let’s try the same, in Heal mode:

As you will see if you click on the image to make it larger, Heal has taken the texture from the baby’s forehead, but adjusted the color and tone/darkness of the fix — made it darker and redder — to fit the destination better.

I find that Heal is almost always the option that works for me.  Occasionally though, because Heal pulls in color and tone from the surrounding area, it can show some bleeding around the edges, which makes the circular fix obvious.  What I advise is that users start in Heal mode, and then if they encounter this bleeding issue, switch to clone mode.

For more on using the spot removal tool, see my video.

Ok, now let’s “fix” the baby’s chin, for the fun of it:

These sorts of things happen when a Photoshop instructor takes my Lightroom class!  (Thank you, Nicole Dement, for the inspiration.)


  4 Responses to “Lightroom Spot Removal in Heal vs. Clone Mode”

  1. Nice and short, just what I wanted to know. Thank you!

  2. Just started reading & watching your tips Laura- recently got Lightroom 5 and on a learning curve. Many Thanks!

  3. Very clear succinct explanation . Thank you.

  4. The web needs to adopt a quick easy “tip jar” where I can leave $1 for things like this. As the first comment says, nice, short — exactly answers my question.

 Leave a Reply


(required, but will not be displayed)

Sign Up Today!
  • Free Video Tutorial Series: Learn Lightroom CC 2015 and Lightroom 6’s New Features!
  • Laura’s Lightroom Newsletter Updates
  • Access to Laura’s Free Live Webinar Broadcasts
  • New Lightroom Video Tutorials and Articles
  • PDF of Laura’s Favorite Lightroom Shortcuts

Your trusted source for all things Lightroom!
I will not share your email. Unsubscribe anytime.